Humble Women, Powerful Nuns

A Female Struggle for Autonomy in a Men’s Church

Kristien Suenens (Author),

Series: KADOC-Studies on Religion, Culture and Society 26

Category: Gender Studies, History 1800-present, Religion

Language: English

ISBN: 9789462702271

Publication date: July 15, 2020

€55.00 (including 6% VAT)

Buy Now

Number of pages: 384

Size: 238 x 170 x 21 mm

Guaranteed Peer Reviewed Content

Stock item: 135988

Standard delivery time for print books:

For Belgium: 5 to 8 working days

For EU: 2 to 3 weeks

For other countries: 4 to 5 weeks

Series: KADOC-Studies on Religion, Culture and Society 26

Category: Gender Studies, History 1800-present, Religion

Language: English

DOI: 10.11116/9789461663276

ISBN: 9789461663276

Publication date: July 15, 2020

€41.00 (including 6% VAT)

Buy Now

Number of pages: 384

Guaranteed Peer Reviewed Content

SHARE

The fascinating story of four ambitious Belgian religious women in a male world

Nineteenth-century female congregation founders could achieve levels of autonomy, power and prestige that were beyond reach for most women of their time. This book recounts the fascinating but ambiguous life stories of four Belgian religious women, hidden for a long time behind a curtain of modesty and mystery. A close reading of their personal writings unveils their conflicted existence: ambitious, socially committed, and audacious on the one hand, suffering, isolated, and dependent on men on the other, they were both victims and promotors of a nineteenth-century ideal of female submission. As religious and social entrepreneurs these women played an influential role in the revival of the Church and the development of education, health care and social provisions in modern Belgium. But, equally well, they were bound to rigid gender patterns and adherents of an ultramontane church ideology that fundamentally distrusted modern society.
This publication is GPRC-labeled (Guaranteed Peer-Reviewed Content).

Introduction

PART I RELIGIOUS REVIVAL, ROMANTICISM AND FEMALE ACTION IN A POST-REVOLUTIONARY AGE: FOUR YOUNG WOMEN (ca. 1820-ca. 1860)

‘Foremothers’, Revolutions and Revival (ca. 1820-ca. 1848)The female pioneers of the revival
Ambiguous images of women
Aut maritus, aut murus? Between marriage and the convent

Female Religious Entrepreneurship on the Offensive (ca. 1848-ca. 1860)Religious education: the female voice of the revival
The need for male support
Enterprising and discursive mechanisms
Social and political tensions and female agency

The Spiritual Dialectic of Revival Devotion“L’ eucharistie peut sauver le monde”
A plurality of devotional practices and ascetic self-denial
A passion paradigm
Female saints as role models

PART II FEMALE AGENCY AT A TURNING POINT: FOUR CONGREGATION FOUNDERS (1857-1867)

Between Longing and Coercion: Spiritual Partnerships“Une religieuse, c’est une paroisse”: frustration and appreciation
Jesuits: irresistible and unavoidable

Soulmates and Rivals: The Power(lessness) of Female AlliancesThe convent as a place of refuge
An alternative family unit: ambiguous female bonding on a micro level
“Autel contre autel”: the limits of a wider female coalition

Mechelen and Rome: Normative Identity and Ecclesiastical PositioningSterckx’s pragmatic policy
Basic feminine inspiration
Male implementation
Containing the revival: the struggle with the contemplative legacy
The crowning accomplishment: a Roman approval

PART III FEMALE ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND LEADERSHIP IN AN ULTRAMONTANE CHURCH: FOUR CONVENT SUPERIORS (ca. 1865-ca. 1885)

Between Dream and Reality: Charisma and NumbersThe story behind two typical congregations
“Les Dames illusionnées”: ambitions and criticism

Convents and Castles: An Uneasy AllianceIn the grip of ultramontane elites
A forced turn to the countryside
“Au comble du bonheur”: women for women
The female alliance challenged

Crusading in a Convent HabitA modern apostolate, conservative ideas
Female agency, the European culture wars and the missionary drive
The inevitability of the crusade: the School War (1879-1884)
The challenge of social Catholicism
Victims and religious entrepreneurs: the spiritual dynamics of ultramontanism

“Pas assez femme”? Female Leadership in Women’s Convents“Une hostie vivante”: institutionalised self-denial
Internal power balances
Lay sisters: women among women

“Domina ista valde facunda est”
Female Leadership in a Male Church
A double-voiced ‘conventualisation’
Gender, power and freedom of conscience: the confessor issue
Roman feminism?

Epilogue
The Shaping of Perceptions
Fanny Kestre: an active “femme forte”, a spiritual “âme simple”
Antoinette Cornet: between oblivion and rediscovery
Anna de Meeûs: “trop robuste pour être sainte”
Wilhelmina Telghuys: always independent

ConclusionA Study in Ambiguity

Timeline

Bibliography

Index of names

Colophon

Kristien Suenens

Kristien Suenens is a senior researcher and consultant for the heritage of religious institutes at KADOC- KU Leuven.

This engaging analysis undoubtedly adds to the scholarly enterprise of gaining a nuanced understanding of female’s involvement in (conservative) religious communities. Although the book focuses on the 19th century, the author relates to contemporary debates within the academic field of religion and gender. In particular, Suenens applies commonly used concepts within the contemporary study of religion and gender such as, among other things, agency, submission, religious entrepreneurship, and autonomy, onto a historical case study.This book is thus not only of interest for historians working on religious and/or gender history, but also for sociologists and ethnographers examining contemporary religious communities and movements in relation to gender. Similar to certain current studies of gender and religion, this research aims to shed light onto the ‘individual motivation, or […] the strategies and challenges of female convent life that could lead to a more nuanced understanding […]’ (p. 19). In doing so, Suenens succeeds to go beyond the simple dichotomy of suppression versus autonomy, and reveals the complexity and ambivalence in female religious subjectivies.
Eline Huygens, Religion and Gender 11, 2021, https://brill.com/view/journals/rag/11/1/article-p148_20.xml, DOI:10.1163/18785417-01101002

Suenens studie ger en inblick i det kvinnliga socialkaritativa ordenslivets utveckling i ett belgiskt perspektiv och illustrerar hur det kom att fungera som en plattform för kvinnors entreprenörskap, nätverksbyggande och frigörelse. Hon belyser också andlighet och religiös mentalitet och illustrerar den religiösa trons funktion som en drivkraft för de biograferade kvinnornas engagemang. Studien bekräftar tidigare forskning men ger också många nya infallsvinklar som kan vara värda att gå vidare med. Detta gäller inte minst den »romerska feminismen», manifesterad i den kyrkliga hierarkins allt starkare intresse av att använda sig av kvinnornas aktiva engagemang i den kyrkliga verksamheten – en trend som förstärkts på senare tid!
Yvonne Maria Werner, Kyrkohistorisk årsskrift 2021

This engaging analysis undoubtedly adds to the scholarly enterprise of gaining a nuanced understanding of female’s involvement in (conservative) religious communities. Although the book focuses on the 19th century, the author relates to contemporary debates within the academic field of religion and gender.

Eline Huygens, Religion and Gender 11 (2021), DOI:10.1163/18785417-01101002

Suenens levert met 'Humble Women, Powerful Nuns' een innovatieve bijdrage aan het onderzoek naar de maatschappelijke positie van vrouwelijke congregatieleiders in negentiende-eeuws België en werpt een nieuw licht op een lang genegeerd onderwerp. Het boek is goed en vlot geschreven, en is doorspekt met citaten uit een gevarieerd bronnencorpus. Hoewel het werk door zijn opzet veel biografische gegevens en relaties tussen netwerken bevat, verzandt Suenens niet in biografische feitelijkheid door de vrouwen onderling voldoende te vergelijken. Een bijkomende meerwaarde is de aandacht die de auteur besteedt aan de relaties van Kestre, de Meeûs, Cornet en Telghuys met het mannelijke klerikale establishment, aristocratische lekenschenkers en andere religieuze vrouwen in binnen- en buitenland. 'Humble Women, Powerful Nuns' is daarmee een gedegen comparatief onderbouwde studie die de complexe maatschappelijke rol van vrouwelijke religieuzen in de negentiende eeuw kadert. Jirki Thibaut, bmgn — Low Countries Historical Review | Volume 136 (2021) | review 55, https://doi.org/10.51769/bmgn-lchr.11296

The implications of Suenens’s research in 'Humble Women, Powerful Nuns' are quite striking: she has opened up many avenues for future work for other historians. How widespread was this view in the global Catholic Church, for example? Why is it that women with financial means were seemingly more exempt from gendered norms andspaces, and how were these lines drawn? How do we account for personality clashes in these complex, patriarchal worlds and the women who break out beyond the private sphere? Extending even further, this book offers a unique historical reflection on the problems still facing Catholic women today, in the form of a hierarchy of virtue inthe Catholic Church, in which personal virtue is pitted against public virtue in expectations of Catholic concepts of “womanhood” and “femininity”. This book should be of interest to scholars well beyond historians of women religious, as it represents new, interesting ways to think about women in history.
Rose Luminiello, Revue d'Histoire Ecclésiastique (vol. 117, 2022/1-2)

Related titles